Blog2023-05-07T12:45:23-06:00

Yoga vs. Antidepressant Drug for Depression: Which Is Better?

Yoga can provide an immediate boost to someone who feels depressed, whereas an antidepressant drug can take weeks to kick in — if at all.

The 2017 125th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association cites studies that support yoga as a natural mood booster.

Lindsey Hopkins, PhD, lead a study on hatha yoga in 23 men with depression.

• Twice a week for eight weeks
• The average enjoyment rating on a one-to-10 scale, given by the subjects, was 9.4.
• After eight weeks there was a significant reduction in depression symptoms.

Another Study Shows Yoga Treats Depression

Freepik.com, prostooleh cobra

Sarah Sahllit, MA, led a study on Bikram yoga’s effect on 52 women.

• More than half participated in twice a week classes for eight weeks.

• The rest was a control group.

• Prior to the study, plus at weeks three, six and nine, the subjects were tested for depression levels.

• Symptoms of depression were significantly reduced after eight weeks in the active group.

A third study, led by Maren Nyer, PhD and Maya Nauphal, BA, showed that eight weeks of yoga twice a week significantly reduced depression symptoms.

Can Yoga Replace an Antidepressant Drug?

Freepik.com yanalya

The person who’s able to go to work every day and run a household — yet feels depressed and may even spend a lot of time in bed on weekends due to a very low mood — is the type of person who can benefit from yoga or other exercise as a mood booster.

This person is already functioning. But what about those who are incapacitated by depression, non-functional?

“I am okay with adding yoga — I do it, but it does not and cannot take the place of medication if someone is truly brain depressed,” says Rupali Chadha, MD, former chief of medical staff at Metropolitan State Hospital in Norwalk, CA.

“Brain depression requires medication, and to recommend anything instead is akin to causing harm to a patient.

“Of course, if someone just has a low mood, yoga will work faster because an antidepressant is NOT indicated, and therefore will simply never work (aside from a placebo effect).”

Not all people who are prescribed an antidepressant have true clinical or brain depression.

When I was a personal trainer, one of my clients — who worked full-time, not to mention showed up for her long-term training sessions with me — was taking Zoloft.

I know a busy businessman who traveled a lot — who took an antidepressant for a short while (which had no effect).

But he must have said something to his doctor to get the prescription.

Some doctors WILL prescribe such drugs if a patient reports certain symptoms.

Some physicians have a lower threshold for when to prescribe than do others.

Yoga or any exercise would not have helped my mother during her deep clinical depression. She was incapacitated and could barely do a simple load of laundry. The only thing that worked was a pharmaceutical.

Yoga for Mood Elevation

Freepik.com/shurkin_son

At the end of a first-time yoga class, a functioning individual who feels depressed will feel some degree of accomplishment.

This may stem from having performed some relatively simple moves that the individual never thought possible.

If you’re feeling down and don’t like the idea of taking a pharmaceutical, you should consider yoga or at least some other form of structured exercise.

In addition to general psychiatry, Dr. Chadha is also a forensic psychiatrist who treats the brain conditions of the criminally insane and serves as an expert witness in trials. She has a passion for fitness plus how the body, mind and spirit come together to build a healthy individual.
Lorra Garrick is a former personal trainer certified through the American Council on Exercise. At Bally Total Fitness she trained women and men of all ages for fat loss, muscle building, fitness and improved health. 
 
.
Top image: Freepik.com
Source: sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/08/170803152917.htm

Can Weight Loss and Exercise Alone Cure Venous Insufficiency?

Venous insufficiency can lead to noticeable varicose veins and sometimes only discoloration and swelling.

Being overweight and under-exercised, according to my lifelong observation of the red/purple and swollen legs of venous insufficiency, seem to be the two conditions strongly linked to these visible characteristics.

Ironically, whenever I see someone with thick varicose veins rippling up and down their legs, that person is never obese and is usually on the trimmer side.

So based on my observations over many years, I asked a vascular surgeon if indeed, only weight loss and a good leg exercise program (squat, leg press, walking lunge) could reduce the visible signs of venous insufficiency.

Now remember, this is about improving an existing problem rather than taking measures (weight control and intense exercise) to actually prevent it from ever developing in the first place.

“Venous insufficiency is a condition related to incompetent vein valves,” says Seyed-Mojtaba Gashti, MD, a board certified vascular surgeon with Broward Health Medical Center in Florida.

“Veins, unlike arteries, carry blood back to the heart, and the veins in our legs have valves to allow blood flow only in one direction: towards the heart.

“If these valves are not functioning well, then the blood would flow down to the legs and over time you developed the varicose veins, swelling, etc.”

This is called venous insufficiency.

“There is no cure for this condition,” continues Dr. Gashti.

“So weight loss and/or exercise will not cure this condition, but they can help reduce the signs and symptoms of it.

“As we walk or use our leg muscles in other ways, the contraction and expansion of the muscles provide a pumping action that helps move blood through these valves.

“Obesity is a known risk factor for cardiovascular disease, and weight loss can be beneficial in that regard; but it also reduces the stress on the veins and may improve the symptoms.”

When I was a personal trainer I never had a client with visible venous insufficiency in the form of swollen reddish or purple legs.

But I did have a client who had painful peripheral vascular disease. Her legs looked normal, but walking was painful, primarily because pressure on her feet from any walking caused pain.

She used a wheelchair in public but was able to walk around the gym.

She was an overweight smoker. Despite these odds stacked against her, she was able to perform leg presses on a machine with an impressive amount of weight – as much as any other typical woman using the same equipment – even more than many, since I’d always encourage my clients to press as much weight as possible (with good form and proper breathing).

I also had her doing high intensity interval training (aka “sprint training”) on a stationary bike.

She was as good as the next woman. I certainly kept her away from the treadmill and walking lunges.

As a fitness enthusiast, I’d like to see more people who have swollen, red or purple legs from venous insufficiency working out in a gym.

With their doctor’s endorsement, they can experiment with various leg exercises and see which ones are tolerable as far as pain.

However, venous insufficiency is not a contraindication to upper body exercise while seated or lying down, such as machine and dumbbell workouts and the bench press!

Though swollen, red and purple legs are unsightly and can be a source of self-consciousness to some people, they may want to wear long sweats or leggings to feel more at ease at a gym. Leggings are extremely common among all women.

But I’d like them to know that many people at gyms have less-than-attractive legs (obesity, cellulite, “chicken” legs, varicose veins) and exercise in shorts nevertheless. And nobody cares!

Even just only upper body workouts (plus dietary control) will help the overweight person with venous insufficiency lose weight, which, as Dr. Gashti points out, can help with this medical condition.

Dr. Gashti specializes in the diagnosis and treatment of vascular disease including abdominal and aortic aneurysm. He received his medical degree from University of New England College of Osteopathic Medicine and has been in practice for more than 20 years.
Lorra Garrick has been covering medical, fitness and cybersecurity topics for many years, having written thousands of articles for print magazines and websites, including as a ghostwriter. She’s also a former ACE-certified personal trainer.  

.

Top image: James Heilman, MD, CreativeCommons
Go to Top